So Carney gets up there and says, “We are no longer relying on just the strength of our values, but also on the value of our strength.”
What in the ever loving fuck does that even mean?
That is not a sentence. That is a fortune cookie that went to business school.
That is what you say when you want applause but you absolutely do not want follow up questions.
If you slow it down for half a second, it is not saying, “Hey, we screwed up and now we are going to actually live by our values.” No. It is saying, “We are still gonna throw our weight around, but now we are gonna feel better about it.”
That kind of language always shows up when consent starts to fail and power has to prepare people for more coercion, as force expands to fill the space where legitimacy once lived.
That is it. Same power. Same outcomes. Just better lighting.
Then he goes, “The WTO, the UN, the COP, the whole architecture of collective problem solving is under threat.”
Oh really.
Under threat from whom?
Reality.
These institutions are not some innocent group project that got vandalized. They were built to manage inequality, not fix it.
They exist so rich countries can say, “Hey, this is all very unfortunate,” while continuing to do exactly what benefits them.
If Carney actually represented Canadian values, he would not be saying, “Oh no, we have to save these institutions.” He would be saying, “Maybe we should fix the fact that these things mostly protect capital and screw everyone else.” But that part is not convenient, so we skip it.
And then he brings out Havel. That is when you know something sneaky is happening.
Havel wrote about resisting the communist regime in Czechoslovakia.
Havel talks about the guy who puts a slogan in his window that nobody believes. The whole point is that the system survives because people keep repeating crap they know is false.
Havel is saying, stop playing along. Stop pretending.
Carney hears that and goes, “Exactly. We should stop pretending.” And then immediately adds, “Except for the pretending that keeps everything basically the same.”
He is not saying live in truth. He is saying, “Hey, that old story does not work anymore. Let us get a new one.”
That is not honesty. That is a rebrand.
And notice which slogans he wants to retire. The ones about the rules based order and moral leadership. Fine. Those are not working anymore. Everyone sees through them.
But the one slogan you never hear. Ever. Is the one that actually explains the mess.
"Workers of the world unite."
That one never makes it onto the stage. Funny how that works.
Except as part of Carney's speech - as the slogan everyone was fighting against.
Because that slogan does not prop the system up. It does not prop the wealthy up. It pulls the floor out from under it. It says the problem is not countries competing. The problem is that a handful of people get rich no matter what flag is flying.
That is why it is dangerous. Not because it is outdated. Because it is still accurate.
If Carney wanted to be honest, he picked the wrong philosopher.
Gramsci would have said, yeah, of course consent is falling apart. It was manufactured in the first place. You told people this was normal until they stopped believing you.
Arendt would have said, all this force and coercion you are calling strength. That is actually weakness. That is what happens when legitimacy is gone and you start panicking.
Du Bois would have gone nuclear and said, let us stop pretending this system was ever fair. Democracy and prosperity at the top were always paid for by somebody else.
But you cannot say that at Davos. You would not make it to dessert.
So instead you get Havel Lite. Truth, but not too much truth. Honesty, but only about the stuff that is already collapsing anyway.
The whole speech is basically, “Yes, the mask cracked. So let us glue it back together and act like this time it is different.”
That is not leadership. That is damage control.
And the funniest part is they keep calling this values.
Values are supposed to cost you something. These values pay dividends.
That is not morality. That is marketing.
